Told in oral history format, Our Noise reads like a late-night conversation between a really interesting group of people (bands from the label’s roster and indie contemporaries like Ian MacKaye and Jenny Toomey, to name a few). The kind of conversation where, at the end of the night, all that’s left is a coffee table littered with empty bottles, ashtrays full of cigarette butts and vague senses of accomplishment and entitlement - the self-righteous but well-deserved “I was there” mentality.
The story goes back to the very beginning, before the bombastic success of Arcade Fire elevated Merge beyond the solid, ever-present force in indie rock it was with a steady stream of releases that supplied enough coal to keep the train moving forward, to what it is now: an honest-to-goodness successful business model with office space, interns, a staff, and benefits for its employees.
How did they get here? It started with two: Mac McCaughan and Laura Ballance. Armed with a love of music and not much else, Merge records started small. Vinyl 7-inches were a cheap, quick way to get music into the hands of the local scenesters and hopefully out to a bigger audience. As the case usually is with independent labels, it was also an opportunity to document the songs of McCaughan and Ballance’s own band Superchunk, formed in 1989. There was little to no money to be made, and Ballance often found herself running the label solo in the beginning while McCaughan was studying at NYC's Columbia University.
Superchunk’s first single on Merge, “Slack Motherfucker,” caught the interest of Matador Records. Matador signed them to a three-record deal while McCaughan and Ballance continued to release other titles on Merge. The subsequent success and popularity of Superchunk kept Merge afloat on more than one occasion, and the fact that Merge is owned and operated by members of Superchunk undoubtedly introduced a lot of the band’s fans to Merge artists. Matador couldn’t hold on to the band for long. Even a bigger independent label was still in bed with politicking and bottom-line focus; ultimately, Superchunk parted ways to find more success on their own label.
After delving into the early years, author Cook talks about some of the label’s more noted and critically acclaimed bands: tales of Butterglory, Lambchop, Neutral Milk Hotel, Magnetic Fields, Spoon and The Arcade Fire are interspersed between more in-depth chapters about Superchunk. The book would not be complete for rabid fans without the skinny on the fabled relationship between McCaughan and Ballance, including an entire chapter about their break-up and the rumors around Foolish, the 1993 full-length indie equivalent of Fleetwood Mac’s Rumours. Final chapters go into detail about the slower pace of the band since 2000 (their last major tour, booked in advance of September 11th and documented in the ’04 documentary Crowding Up Your Visual Field, was emotionally and physically draining with sparse turnouts thanks to the undercurrent of fear that 9/11 engendered) versus the overwhelming success of the label.
What makes this book a success story? There are countless failed independent labels that faded into the ether after a few years or became swallowed up by bigger fish. How has Merge kept their doors open?Smart financial decisions, good distribution (first through Touch and Go and most recently through industry giant Alternative Distribution Alliance or ADA), and an ear for music. But the collective ears of Merge aren’t on the lookout for bands that would sell enough records to make soundscan overheat and shutdown - they seek out music that resonates with the listener and registers an emotional response. The six-plus pages listing Merge’s complete discography is proof of that. Congratulations on 20 years, Merge - your label is a benchmark of good taste and an example of how to run a business with integrity, and this book is a great way to celebrate.




Post new comment