Merge Records & Superchunk:
An interview with Mac McCaughan
Words: Susie Ulrey
Is Merge Records really 20 years old? Think back to the first Superchunk album you bought - was it on tape? From a local record shop thats went belly-up years ago? Then yes, it really has been that long. I talked with underground icon Mac McCaughan via e-mail about the launch of the forthcoming book Our Noise: The Story of Merge Records, The Indie Label That Got Big And Stayed Small, as well as his indie rock institution/label Merge and his watershed band Superchunk.
REAX: What is your proudest moment for Merge? For Superchunk?
MM: For Merge ... everyone at the label working together to put together something big like our 20th anniversary festival last month is a satisfying moment, but really the pride is more about the artists on Merge - each time someone makes an astounding record - than it is being proud of "Merge the label.” For Superchunk, when we play a great show it's a good feeling, or when we step out of our normal comfort zone to do something like the Page of Madness silent film live soundtrack a few years ago, that's something I'm proud of. I'm proud of at least parts of all of our records ...
REAX: Based on your own personal taste, what is your favorite Merge band/release?
MM: Ha! You won't get an answer to that one. We love them all!
REAX: What advice would you give to a start-up bedroom indie label?
MM: First, I would say, don't start a label, there are too many! But if it will be a good label, then I would say, don't do it if you want it to be your career - do it because you think it will be fun and you love the music that you're working with. If you plan on it becoming something else, chances are you're in for a frustrating time of it! But then if it does, you could be pleasantly surprised.
REAX: Why a book? Why presented as an oral history?
MM: Why a book? Good question ... because someone proposed it to us! And we had a lot of great snapshots. The scope of the interviews and the number of voices meant that an oral history made the most sense as a way to present something that a lot of people had a hand in, and probably have slightly different memories of ... also, I love reading oral histories, I think it's a great way to learn about something from many angles at once.
REAX: What sets Merge apart from other independent labels?
MM: When I think about labels that are important to me, or were when I was younger, they each have their own character, so really they're all different from each other and so is Merge. The roster, the owners, the presentation of the music, the cover art ... a personality comes through in all of those elements, even though it may be hard to nail down precisely what that personality is. I think our goals and the way we think about music may be similar to a label like Matador or Sub Pop or K or Teen Beat or Touch and Go or Dead Oceans or Saddle Creek. There are many other great labels I'm not thinking of off the top of my head.
REAX: What was the turning point - when did Merge become incorporated, get a tax ID and turn into an actual business as opposed to a labor of love?
MM: We got all those things a long time ago, but it's still a labor of love.
REAX: As a flagship band for the label post-Matador, how did you balance your focus on Superchunk vs. the label?
MM: You tend to what needs you - for a long time, Merge was so small and Superchunk was growing so fast, it was obvious that being on tour and making Superchunk records was our focus, and it needed to be. As Superchunk started slowing down, some other bands on Merge really started becoming well-known and selling more records and the balance of time spent on the road vs. in the office gradually switched over. Now we kind of do Superchunk in short bursts, rather than four-month tours, and spend most of our time at Merge.
REAX: In retrospect, would you still shy away from contracts for as long as you did?
MM: Sure. If you do business in the handshake style, which is a friendly way to do business, for the first ten years or so and you only get slightly burned a couple of times, that's a pretty good trade-off, I think. I still hate negotiating contracts - easily the worst part of the job - but we realize we need to do it.
REAX: What do you look for in a Merge release? Are the bands solicited or do you consider CDs mailed to you - how many do you receive on an annual basis?
MM: I don't have any idea how many CDs we get every year, and I don't want to know! That's a lot of waste. But we do consider things that just come over the transom. Luckily, we get fewer CDs now and more emails saying "here's a link to our new album". I say luckily because it means we don't have to throw away a CD and an envelope and recycle someone's press kit. Then again, I'm even less likely to listen to a demo online - I hate listening to music on my computer. Mostly we find out about new stuff because I buy a lot of records and am constantly seeking out new music for myself anyway, or because a friend recommends something, or a band on Merge recommends someone they just did a show with or something.
REAX: Your kids turn 20: they tell you they want to start a record label. What’s your reaction?
MM: I suppose I couldn't really say anything besides "go for it!", could I?
REAX: What would you do differently, in hindsight - with Superchunk and Merge?
MM: Nothing that I can think of, stuff goes by so quickly it doesn't really help to dwell on the stuff you didn't do. Actually, I would have made a new Superchunk record by now!
REAX: If you had to choose band vs. label, how would you make that decision? Or are the two inextricably linked?
MM: Well, they're linked historically but not really linked beyond that, except maybe in people's perception, which is fine. We can have the label forever but I will still think of myself primarily as a musician and songwriter.
REAX: How has becoming a parent changed your goals for the band and the label?
MM: Less touring for sure, but other than that I think it would be weird if we started doing things differently just because we have kids. I suppose we could start putting parental warning stickers on the Lambchop albums?
REAX: Superchunk: what’s in the future? Will you tour again?
MM: I don't think we'll ever tour like we used to tour, but we'll hopefully finish a new album at some point and keep doing shows when we feel like it! I like our new single and the shows we played last month were a couple of my favorites.
Our Noise comes out September 15 on Algonquin Books. Check out our review here.



Post new comment